Best Benjamin Moore gray paint colors

Gray paint has been one of the biggest home decor trends of the last decade. Being neutral and sophisticated, shades of gray will suit a wide array of styles. If you’re considering gray for your next home decorating project, start with Benjamin Moore. Not only is the paint high quality, but the best Benjamin Moore gray paint colors are downright gorgeous.

This website uses affiliate links which may earn a commission for purchases made at no additional cost to you.

The only challenge? Which one to pick.

With dozens of gray tones, choosing the best Benjamin Moore gray can be tough – but in a good way! In this post, we round up the best Benjamin Moore gray paint colors. These colors are the brand’s top sellers, which means they’re the ones homeowners and designers choose again and again. A good place to start, right? Once you go through them, you will pick the right fit for your needs.

The 12 best Benjamin Moore gray paint colors

Here’s a roundup of BM’s top grays. Some are warm, some are cool, others are neutral – and you can’t go wrong with any of them!

1. Stonington Gray

Stonington Gray features an LRV of 59.36, a gorgeous medium gray tone. It is a cool gray with a subtle blue undertone that can find its way into many different styles. It is a versatile silvery gray that is more on the neutral side. The color flatters crisp whites with a cool undertone. It pairs perfectly with white trim, creating a modern interior with a sleek finish. On the other hand, Stonington Gray isn’t reserved only for the interiors. It will make an ideal choice for a house exterior paint and can be complemented with both white and darker gray trim for a modern look. 

2. Edgecomb Gray

If you need a subtle color that belongs in the gray family Edgecomb Gray is a good choice. It is somewhere between a beige and a gray tone and has a moderate amount of warmth. It brings an organic feel to the space while being versatile enough to flatter a wide range of colors. This paint color doesn’t have prominent undertones, so you will find it easier to implement in your home. However, keep in mind that the undertone can vary depending on the lighting conditions. Overall, Edgecomb Gray is a distinctive gray color with an LRV of 63.09.

3. Revere Pewter

Grays can be cool or warm, but Revere Pewter stands somewhere between them. It is a gorgeous neutral gray with an LRV of 55.05, sitting in the middle of the scale. It is one of Benjamin Moore’s bestsellers and part of the Historical Colors collection. Revere Pewter is a light to mid-toned gray with a warm undertone. Also, it has an earthy and natural feel, ideal for rustic styles. It tends to feel warmer than other cool grays in Benjamin Moore’s collection (akin to Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray). However, it might pick up a cool gray tone in specific light conditions. 

4. Gray Owl

With an LRV of 64.51, Gray Owl is a light gray color classified as a warm one. However, it won’t look too warm on your walls. It has a green undertone that gives warmth but can still look cool under specific light conditions. Gray Owl is an excellent choice for modern homes, pairing perfectly with white trim. 

5. Wickham Gray

Wickham Gray is a light gray with an LRV of 67.87. It is a cool gray tone with green and blue undertones. Under specific light conditions, its colder side might be more dominant. However, it will pair excellently with warm whites for trim. For curating a color scheme, it will pair nicely with warm grays and darker grays. 

6. Gray Cloud

Gray Cloud belongs to the cool grays in Benjamin Moore’s collection. It has a subtle blue undertone (but not quite as blue as the popular Benjamin Moore Smoke) so it has a calming and soothing effect. This would make Gray Cloud the ideal paint choice for bedrooms and nurseries. With an LRV of 69.7, it is a light gray that fits modern spaces perfectly. With being versatile enough, you can match it with off whites and darker grays for a neutral color scheme. 

7. Wish

Wish is a medium gray shade with an LRV of 58.58. It is a warm-toned gray that appears relatively neutral to the eye. Therefore it is a perfect choice if you aren’t keen on prominent undertones. However, keep in mind that its yellow undertones will be more dominant in south-facing rooms. 

8. Stormy Monday

If you are looking for a moody gray, Stormy Monday might be an ideal pick. The cool undertone makes this paint color a perfect selection for modern and sophisticated spaces. With an LRV of 40.54, it is a gorgeous medium gray color that makes a statement. Under specific light conditions, its violet undertone will be more noticeable. When curating the ultimate color scheme, it would be best to stick with earthy browns or cool grays. 

9. Metropolitan

Metropolitan is a cool gray that flatters modern and sleek styles. In 2019, it was announced as the color of the year. It is an adaptable paint color with a cool undertone. The gray tone can balance other warmth elements in the space, creating a harmonious finish. Also, it is a medium-dark tone that will make a statement with its depth. However, it isn’t too dark gray and will work perfectly for open-plan homes.

10. Silver Half Dollar

Gray is the most popular choice for living rooms and bedrooms. If you are looking for a true gray that feels airy, this might be the right fit for your needs. Silver Half Dollar is a light gray with cool undertones. With an LRV of 56.9 and a silvery look, it is a perfect subtle paint color for bedrooms or other spaces that crave tranquility. This color works nicely with off whites and dark grays in the form of accents. 

11. Thunder

Thunder is a gorgeous greige color that will flatter any space. It achieves the perfect balance between gray and beige without exaggerated warm tones that appear yellowish. With an LRV of 47.58, Thunder is a mid-toned gray that provides a neutral backdrop. When compared to the popular Edgecomb Gray, it is a darker gray. Every gray paint color has undertones, which might be more noticeable under different light conditions. However, Thunder doesn’t have strong undertones making it easier to work with. However, you might still notice a hint of purple in north-facing rooms. Overall, Thunder will keep its neutral side and flatter a wide range of styles. It is an excellent choice for painting the house exterior, as the direct sunlight will lighten up this medium tone. 

12. Kendall Charcoal

Charcoal tones are popular in the designer’s world, introducing luxury and sophistication into the space. Kendall Charcoal from Benjamin Moore is a good pick if you need a deep and rich gray to make a bold statement. It has varying undertones, making this color easy to work with. With an LRV of 14.61, it is positioned low on the scale. Its proximity to zero means it is pretty close to black, but it remains in the dark gray category. It would make an ideal choice for moody and dramatic kitchen cabinets. Also, the charcoal tone will add depth to a room in the form of an accent wall. Or you can paint the front door in this deep tone for a modern touch. 

Final thoughts

With so many grays to choose from, it is challenging to make a final decision. However, keep in mind that you shouldn’t stick with your preference only. Be sure to check how the chosen gray tone behaves under specific light conditions and when positioned next to other colors. Since the type of lighting can bring out different undertones, you would want to test with a sample before committing to a specific tone.