How to Make Your Pumpkins Last For Months -

My porch, with my pumpkins in all their preserved glory.

A few years ago, I posted a TikTok about how to make pumpkins last, and I was surprised to see how many people commented that they’d never heard of the method I’d used.

I started preserving my pumpkins a while back for a few reasons:

First and foremost: I like to decorate for fall early, like right after Labor Day early. Which means all of my fall porch decor needs to last until at least Halloween, which is about 8 weeks. If you’ve ever had to throw your soggy pumpkins out before you even got a chance to carve them for Halloween, then you know most pumpkins don’t make it 8 weeks.

Second, I’ve found that the squirrels in my area are just ruthless when it comes to pumpkins. Ruthless. They have zero regard for my painstaking styling, and burrow their way into the middle of the pumpkins on my porch the first chance they get.

I’d tried a number of tricks that are supposed to keep squirrels away from pumpkins, like spraying them with hairspray, and spraying them with hot sauce, and neither worked for me ….

But then, I found a trick that literally makes pumpkins last for months…

So how do I preserve pumpkins?

My method for preserving pumpkins is very easy. You can watch my video on how to preserve pumpkins below or skip it and keep reading for a short and sweet overview.

@kaitmadden How to spray paint fall pumpkins so they last longer ? #pumpkindiy #pumpkins #frontporch #fallporch ♬ Fancy Like – Walker Hayes

My Trick for Making Pumpkins Last, Step-by-Step

Wipe it down. Wipe the pumpkin down so there’s no dirt or dust on it. No need to scrub it, just use a damp towel and give it a good wipe. Then let it dry.
Spray it with spray enamel. I use Rustoleum Clear Gloss Spray Enamel. I’ve never used any other brand or finish. I’m sure they’re all fine but I can only vouch for the Rustoleum kind. I usually give it a couple of coats to make sure the whole pumpkin is covered.
Let it dry. I let my pumpkins dry for about an hour, though they will be dry to the touch in a few minutes, just to make sure they’re nice and cured before putting them on my steps. I put my pumpkins on concrete and stone steps, but if you’re putting your pumpkins on a wood surface, I might wait a little longer just to be sure the enamel is good and cured so it won’t come off on the wood.

Also – it’s important to note that spray enamel should ideally be used outside, or in a well-ventilated area with a respirator. You don’t want to be huffing this stuff.

Does preserving pumpkins actually work?

One question I got a lot when I first shared this pumpkin preservation trick is,’ this sounds cool and all, but does preserving a pumpkin with enamel actually work?’ And it does! Spraying pumpkins with enamel not only kept my them from rotting for two months, it also kept squirrels away completely, which was a huge change from past years when they were eaten in just a few weeks.

For proof that the trick works, I filmed another video of what the pumpkins looked like right before I threw them out. I sprayed the pumpkins in early September, and I threw them away in November. As an experiment, and because I was lazy, when I added a few more pumpkins to our porch setup later on, I left them au natural, and then I compared the two in the video before I got rid of them.

@kaitmadden An update on my pumpkins! The trick works ?? #halloweenathome #pumpkins #homehacks #scarystories #halloweentreats #homeproject #frontporchdecor ♬ Adams Family Theme Song – Halloween DJ's

You can see in my video that the pumpkins that were sprayed had almost no rotting, while the one that I didn’t spray was swarming with flies and completely rotten. You can also see that the sprayed look a bit glossier than the first pumpkin, which wasn’t sprayed.

Can you compost a preserved pumpkin?

The one thing I don’t like about preserving pumpkins is that, once you do it, you can’t compost them. We compost all of our family’s food waste, so I don’t love that I have to throw these away. The enamel makes the pumpkins unfit for composting. It’s also not a good idea to leave them out for animals to eat, again because the enamel makes them unsafe.